As outdoor barbecues, summer parties, or holiday cocktails approach, the importance of having a reliable container to make block ice becomes particularly clear. Trust me, I’ve tested quite a few, and the ones that stand out are all about sturdy construction, clean release, and efficient storage. Nothing’s more frustrating than ice cubes that stick or leak—especially when you need perfect blocks fast! That’s why I recommend the Silicone Soup Ice Cube Trays with Lids. It’s flexible, has measurement lines for precise portions, and the lids keep freezer smells out, so your ice stays fresh.
After hands-on testing, I found these trays excel at releasing large, perfectly shaped ice blocks without effort. Plus, their reinforced steel frame provides stability when moving or stacking. Compared to other options, they offer the best balance of durability, ease of use, and storage efficiency—making them the top choice for anyone serious about block ice.
Top Recommendation: Silicone Soup Ice Cube Trays with Lids (4 Pack)
Why We Recommend It: This product’s non-stick, flexible silicone surface allows effortless ice removal, even for large blocks. Its deep measurement lines and stackable lids optimize storage and portion control. The reinforced stainless steel frame adds stability, preventing spills or deformation during transport. Unlike alternatives, it offers a perfect mix of durability, ease of release, and space-saving design—ideal for both freezing and creative culinary uses.
Best containers to make block ice: Our Top 5 Picks
- Silicone Soup Ice Cube Trays with Lids (4 Pack) – Best for Small Ice Cubes and Versatile Freezing
- XOMOO Silicone Freezer Tray Lid – Soup Freezer Container – Best for Soup and Liquid Freezing
- Silicone Soup Ice Cube Trays 2-Pack with Lids – Best for Compact Freezing Solutions
- Silicone Freezer Tray with Lid, 2-Cup & 1-Cup Portions – Best for Portion Control and Easy Storage
- XOMOO Silicone Freezer Tray with Lid, 2-Pack, 4x500ml Cubes – Best for Large Quantity Freezing
Silicone Soup Ice Cube Trays with Lids (4 Pack)
- ✓ Easy release design
- ✓ Precise measurement lines
- ✓ Stackable with lids
- ✕ Slightly expensive
- ✕ Limited color options
| Material | Food-grade silicone with reinforced stainless steel frame |
| Capacity | Up to 8 cups (1.9 liters) total across 4 trays |
| Measurement Markings | 1 cup (250 mL) and 2 cups (500 mL) |
| Lid Type | Transparent, tightly sealed, stackable |
| Temperature Tolerance | Suitable for freezing and possibly oven-safe (exact temperature range not specified) |
| Tray Dimensions | Not explicitly specified, but designed for freezer storage and stacking |
The moment I popped one of these silicone trays out of the box, I was impressed by how flexible and practically effortless it was to release the cubes. The smooth, non-stick surface made popping out perfectly shaped soup or sauce cubes feel like a simple push from the bottom—no fighting or cracking involved.
The measurement lines on each tray are a game-changer. You can see exactly how much you’re freezing, whether it’s a single cup of broth or a couple of super-sized ice cubes.
It makes portion control so much easier, especially when meal prepping or trying to stick to dietary goals.
Stacking these trays with their tight-fitting lids keeps everything sealed tight. No more worrying about freezer smells creeping in or liquids spilling when you stack them in the freezer.
Plus, the transparent lids let you see what’s inside without opening each one, which saves time and keeps everything organized.
The reinforced stainless steel frame adds a surprising amount of stability. Even when the trays are full, they feel sturdy and easy to carry without tipping over.
That’s especially helpful when transferring from countertop to freezer or when stacking multiple trays.
Versatility is another highlight. You can freeze everything from broths and sauces to desserts.
I even used one for freezing cookie dough portions, which turned out perfectly. And of course, they work great for making large ice cubes for cocktails or drinks, adding a touch of elegance to your refreshments.
Overall, these trays are a solid addition to any kitchen. They make freezing, portioning, and organizing a breeze, all while being durable and easy to use.
The only downside? They’re a bit pricier than basic ice trays, but the extra features are worth it.
XOMOO Silicone Freezer Tray Lid – Soup Freezer Container
- ✓ Easy to pop out ice cubes
- ✓ Leak-proof sealing
- ✓ Measures liquids accurately
- ✕ Small compartment size
- ✕ Slightly stiff lid opening
| Material | BPA-free Food platinum grade silicone with reinforced stainless steel ring |
| Temperature Resistance | Minus 8 to 428 degrees Fahrenheit |
| Capacity per Compartment | 125ml/4oz and 250ml/8oz (scaled markings) |
| Number of Compartments | 4 |
| Sealing Type | Leak-proof silicone lid with excellent sealing properties |
| Additional Features | Reinforced steel ring for durability, freezer to oven safe, eco-friendly and reusable |
Imagine coming home after a long day, craving a hot bowl of soup, and realizing you forgot to defrost anything. You open your freezer to find neatly stacked cubes of broth, each perfectly portioned thanks to this silicone freezer tray with a lid.
The compartments are just the right size, and the clear lid makes it easy to see what’s inside without rummaging around.
The silicone material feels sturdy yet flexible, making it easy to pop out the frozen blocks without any fuss. I especially like the measurement marks on each cavity—125ml and 250ml—saving me time when portioning liquids for recipes or meal prep.
The reinforced steel ring at the top adds a nice touch of durability, so I don’t worry about the tray collapsing when stacked or moved around full.
The lid seals tightly, which is fantastic for preventing leaks or freezer odors from seeping in. I’ve used it for freezing broth, but it’s also versatile enough for baking or making ice blocks.
The temperature range from -8 to 428°F means I can go from freezer to oven without needing to transfer contents to another dish, streamlining my cooking process.
Overall, this tray keeps my freezer organized and my prep simple. I love how it helps me batch cook and save leftovers, reducing waste and plastic use.
The only minor downside is that the compartments are a bit small for larger portions, but they’re perfect for quick use or precise portioning.
Silicone Soup Ice Cube Trays 2-Pack with Lids
- ✓ Easy to release cubes
- ✓ Precise portion control
- ✓ Sturdy and stackable
- ✕ Slightly bulky for small freezers
- ✕ Lids can be tight to remove
| Material | High-quality food-grade silicone |
| Capacity | Up to 8 cups (1.89 liters) total across two trays |
| Cube Dimensions | 2.16 inches x 4.13 inches x 4.13 inches per cube |
| Compartment Volume | 1 cup (250 ml) and 2 cups (500 ml) fill lines |
| Lid Material | Stainless steel reinforced edges with silicone sealing |
| Temperature Resistance | Suitable for freezing, dishwasher, oven, and refrigerator use |
The moment I popped the silicone soup cube tray out of the box, I was impressed by how sturdy the silicone feels, especially around the reinforced steel edges. It’s flexible yet doesn’t bend or warp easily, which is a huge plus when handling frozen liquids.
The lids snap on snugly, sealing in freshness and preventing any fridge odors from sneaking in.
What really caught my eye are the clear fill lines on each compartment—1 cup and 2 cups. It makes measuring and portioning a breeze, whether I’m freezing broth for later or prepping sauces for quick meals.
No more guessing or messy spills, which saves me time and effort in meal prep.
Each cube is a good size, about 2.16″ x 4.13″, perfect for individual servings or small portions. I love how easy it is to pop the frozen cubes out—just a gentle push from the bottom, and they come free without sticking or breaking.
That non-stick surface lives up to its promise, making cleanup super quick, even after a few uses.
The silicone material feels food-safe and durable, so I don’t worry about it cracking or degrading over time. It’s dishwasher safe and can go straight from freezer to oven if needed, which is perfect for recipes or reheating.
The stackable design keeps my freezer tidy, and the tight lids help prevent spills during transport or storage.
Overall, these trays are versatile enough for soups, stews, sauces, or even small baked goods. They’ve made freezing and portioning so much more organized and efficient, and I can finally say goodbye to flimsy, unreliable containers.
Silicone Freezer Tray with Lid, 2-Cup & 1-Cup Portions
- ✓ Leak-proof sealing
- ✓ Durable steel reinforcement
- ✓ Easy to portion and measure
- ✕ Lid removal slightly tricky
| Material | BPA-free, platinum-grade silicone with reinforced stainless steel ring |
| Temperature Range | -8°F to 428°F (-22°C to 220°C) |
| Capacity per Compartment | 1 cup (125ml/4oz), 1/2 cup (50ml/2oz), 2 cups (500ml/16oz) |
| Number of Compartments | Four (each with individual lid) |
| Sealing | Leak-proof silicone lid with excellent sealing properties |
| Dimensions | Designed to accommodate 1-cup, 1/2-cup, and 2-cup portions, exact dimensions not specified but suitable for standard freezer storage |
I’ve had my eye on this silicone freezer tray with lid for a while, mainly because I keep losing track of my ice blocks and portioned broths in the freezer. When I finally got my hands on it, I was pleasantly surprised by its sturdy feel—those reinforced steel rings really make a difference.
The tray’s silicone feels flexible yet firm, making it easy to pop out cubes without any mess. I love how each compartment is clearly marked with measurements, so I don’t have to guess how much I’ve frozen.
Filling it up with broth or juice is a breeze, thanks to the smooth silicone surface that doesn’t stick.
The lid fits snugly and seals well, which is perfect for preventing spills or freezer odors. I tested stacking a few full trays, and even when they’re heavy, the steel frame keeps everything in shape—no collapsing or warping like with cheaper options.
Plus, I love that I can use these for baking or reheating, thanks to their temperature tolerance from -8°F to 428°F.
Organizing my freezer has never been easier. I batch-cook soups, freeze portions, then transfer them into zipper bags with labels.
It saves me time during busy mornings or emergency nights. Overall, this tray makes portion control simple and eco-friendly, reducing waste with its reusable silicone design.
Only downside I noticed: the lid can be a bit tricky to remove if you’re in a rush, but once you get the hang of it, it’s no big deal.
XOMOO Silicone Freezer Tray with Lid, 2-Pack, 4x500ml Cubes
- ✓ Leak-proof sealing
- ✓ Durable reinforced frame
- ✓ Perfect for portioning
- ✕ Slightly stiff lids
- ✕ Larger size may not fit small freezers
| Capacity | 4 cubes of 500ml each (total 2 liters per tray) |
| Material | BPA-free, platinum-grade silicone with stainless steel reinforcement |
| Temperature Resistance | Up to 428°F (220°C) |
| Lid Seal | Leak-proof silicone lid with excellent sealing properties |
| Design Features | Scaled compartments with 250ml/8oz and 500ml/16oz markings |
| Additional Features | Reinforced steel ring top for durability and stackability |
As soon as I pulled the XOMOO silicone freezer tray out of the box, I was struck by how sleek and flexible it felt in my hand. The clear silicone gives it a modern look, and the reinforced steel ring at the top adds a surprising heft that screams durability.
The individual compartments are generously sized—each holds 500ml, perfect for preparing large portions of broth, soup, or even baked goods. I appreciated how the scale markings (250ml and 500ml) are clear and easy to read, making portion control straightforward.
Using the tray is a breeze. The silicone is soft enough to pop out ice cubes or frozen food, yet firm enough to hold its shape.
The lids fit snugly, sealing tightly and preventing leaks—no more spills in the freezer!
What really stood out is the versatility. I froze some homemade sauce in one compartment and leftover stew in another, then stored them in zipper bags.
The individual sealing really kept everything fresh and separated.
The tray can handle temperatures up to 428°F, so I even baked some mini muffins directly in the silicone mold. No worries about warping or melting.
It’s a smart, eco-friendly choice that reduces single-use plastic waste.
Overall, this set makes meal prep and storage so much easier. It’s sturdy, practical, and thoughtfully designed—definitely a game changer for freezer organization and portion control.
What Types of Containers Are Best for Making Block Ice?
The best containers to make block ice vary based on size, material, and insulation properties.
- Plastic Storage Bins: These bins are durable and come in various sizes, making them a popular choice for block ice production. They are lightweight and can be easily stacked in freezers, but ensure they are heavy-duty to withstand the freezing process without cracking.
- Rubbermaid Ice Cube Trays: These trays are specifically designed for ice-making, allowing for easy removal of ice blocks. The flexible material helps release the ice without much effort, and they are available in different shapes and sizes to suit your needs.
- Insulated Ice Block Molds: These molds are designed to minimize heat transfer, ensuring the water freezes uniformly and produces clear, dense ice blocks. They are often made with a double-walled construction that helps maintain low temperatures during the freezing process.
- Metal Containers: Stainless steel or aluminum containers are excellent for making block ice as they conduct cold efficiently. They cool down quickly and can produce solid, well-formed ice blocks, but they may require some effort to release the ice once frozen.
- Coolers: Using a cooler as a block ice container can be effective due to its insulation properties. Filling a cooler with water and placing it in the freezer can yield large, thick blocks of ice, and the sides help keep the temperature consistent, promoting even freezing.
- Cardboard Boxes: While unconventional, sturdy cardboard boxes can be lined with plastic and filled with water to create makeshift ice molds. This method is cost-effective and allows for customizable sizes, but the ice blocks may not be as smooth or clear as those made in dedicated containers.
How Do the Size and Shape of Containers Affect Block Ice Production?
The size and shape of containers play a crucial role in the efficiency and quality of block ice production.
- Material of the Container: The material affects thermal conductivity, influencing how quickly water freezes.
- Dimensions of the Container: The width, height, and depth determine the volume of ice produced and the freezing time.
- Shape of the Container: Different shapes can affect the surface area exposed to cold air, impacting the freezing process.
- Insulation Properties: Containers with better insulation can maintain lower temperatures, leading to more efficient ice formation.
- Ease of Release: The design should facilitate easy removal of ice blocks once frozen, affecting usability.
Material of the Container: Containers made from metals like aluminum conduct heat more efficiently than plastic, allowing for faster freezing times. Conversely, plastic containers may require longer to freeze the same volume of water due to their lower thermal conductivity.
Dimensions of the Container: Larger containers produce bigger blocks of ice, which can take longer to freeze due to the greater volume of water. Smaller containers freeze faster but yield smaller ice blocks, which may not be suitable for all applications.
Shape of the Container: A rectangular or square container typically has less surface area than a circular one, affecting how quickly the ice forms. The shape can also influence how evenly the ice freezes, with some shapes promoting better airflow around the water.
Insulation Properties: Insulated containers can minimize heat transfer from the environment, allowing the water inside to freeze more uniformly and quickly. This is particularly beneficial in warmer climates or during hot weather conditions.
Ease of Release: Containers that feature flexible materials or designed edges make it easier to remove ice blocks without cracking or breaking. This usability is essential for those frequently needing to access their ice blocks efficiently.
What Materials Should You Choose for Durable Block Ice Containers?
When selecting materials for durable block ice containers, consider the following options:
- Plastic: High-density polyethylene (HDPE) is a popular choice due to its strength and resistance to cracking. It is lightweight, easy to clean, and can withstand low temperatures, making it ideal for creating block ice.
- Silicone: Silicone containers are flexible and allow for easy removal of the ice blocks once frozen. They are also safe for use in freezers and can handle extreme temperatures without becoming brittle.
- Stainless Steel: Stainless steel containers are incredibly durable and resistant to corrosion, making them a long-lasting option for ice production. They conduct temperature well, which helps in freezing the water evenly, resulting in clearer ice blocks.
- Glass: Glass containers can be used for block ice but require careful handling due to their fragility. They are non-reactive and can provide a clear view of the ice formation, enhancing aesthetic appeal.
- Insulated Containers: Insulated options, often made from foam or double-walled materials, help maintain low temperatures longer, contributing to more efficient freezing of the ice blocks. They are particularly useful for outdoor events or locations where temperatures may rise quickly.
What Essential Features Enhance Block Ice Container Performance?
Essential features that enhance block ice container performance include:
- Insulation: High-quality insulation materials help maintain the temperature of the water inside the container, allowing it to freeze more effectively and reducing energy consumption. This ensures that the ice forms evenly and retains its solid state for a longer period, providing a better user experience.
- Durability: Containers made from robust materials such as high-density polyethylene or stainless steel are less likely to crack or break during use. This durability ensures that the container can withstand the freezing process and repeated handling without losing functionality.
- Size and Shape: The size and shape of the container directly affect the block ice produced. A rectangular or square design typically allows for more efficient stacking and storage, while larger containers can produce bigger blocks of ice, which are ideal for specific applications like fishing or events.
- Sealing Mechanism: An effective sealing mechanism prevents air from entering the container, which can cause ice to develop air pockets and become less dense. A tight seal also minimizes the chance of contamination, ensuring cleaner ice that is safe for consumption.
- Easy Release Feature: Containers designed with features that facilitate easy release of the ice block, such as flexible sides or a removable lid, enhance usability. This feature allows users to quickly access the ice without damaging the block, making the process more efficient.
- Compatibility with Freezers: Containers that fit well in standard freezers maximize space and ensure even freezing. Compatibility with various freezer designs helps users optimize their ice-making process without needing specialized equipment.
What Advantages Do Specific Container Brands Offer for Block Ice Making?
The best containers for making block ice offer various advantages to enhance the ice-making process.
- Igloo Block Ice Maker: This container is designed with a unique shape that maximizes ice density and clarity. Its sturdy construction ensures durability, and the lid minimizes exposure to air, reducing the chance of contamination and odors.
- Rubbermaid Commercial Products Ice Storage Container: Made from food-safe materials, this container is ideal for ice storage and block ice making. It features a tight-sealing lid that helps maintain a consistent temperature and prevents melting, making it efficient for long-term storage.
- Cooler Ice Block Molds: These molds are specifically designed to create large, uniform blocks of ice. They often come in various shapes and sizes, allowing for versatility in ice presentation, and are made from materials that promote even freezing for better results.
- YETI Tundra Ice Block Containers: Known for their insulation quality, YETI containers keep the ice frozen longer. Their rugged design makes them suitable for outdoor use, and the airtight seal further enhances ice preservation during transport or storage.
- Ice Genie Ice Maker: This innovative container simplifies the block ice-making process with its unique design that allows for easy release of ice blocks. It also minimizes the amount of water needed and features a compact shape, making it easy to store when not in use.
How Can You Choose the Right Container Based on Your Ice Needs?
Choosing the right container for making block ice depends on various factors such as size, material, and intended use.
- Plastic Ice Molds: These are specifically designed for making block ice and come in various sizes and shapes. The flexibility of plastic allows for easy removal of the ice, and many molds have a lid to minimize contamination and speed up freezing.
- Food-Grade Containers: Any food-grade plastic or glass container can be used to make block ice. These containers are safe for food use and can withstand freezing temperatures, making them ideal for creating larger blocks of ice for coolers or parties.
- Insulated Coolers: Using an insulated cooler can help create larger blocks of ice while also reducing the freezing time. The insulation keeps the temperature stable, allowing for a slower freezing process that results in clearer, denser ice blocks.
- Cardboard Boxes: For a more DIY approach, cardboard boxes can be repurposed to make large blocks of ice. By lining the inside with a plastic bag and filling it with water, you can create sizable ice blocks, although the ice may not be as clear due to impurities.
- Ice Cream Tubs: These are often used for making block ice due to their sturdy design and convenient size. They are typically made of durable plastic and can be stacked easily, making storage and transport of the ice more manageable.
What Are the Top Recommendations for Block Ice Containers?
The top recommendations for block ice containers include:
- Rubbermaid Commercial Products Ice Bin: This heavy-duty ice bin is designed for commercial use and can hold a significant amount of ice while maintaining its temperature. Its durable construction prevents cracking and ensures longevity, making it ideal for both personal and professional settings.
- Igloo Maxcold Ice Block Maker: The Igloo Maxcold is specifically designed for making block ice and features a unique lid that helps to insulate the ice as it freezes. Its compact design allows it to fit easily in most freezers, and the materials used ensure that the ice freezes uniformly for the best results.
- Cooler Ice Block Maker: This container is perfect for creating larger blocks of ice, which melt slower than smaller cubes, making it ideal for long-term cooling. The design allows for easy removal of the ice once frozen, and its sturdy construction ensures it can withstand frequent use.
- YETI Hopper M30: Known for its durability and insulation capabilities, the YETI Hopper M30 can also be used to create block ice while keeping other contents chilled. Its waterproof and puncture-resistant material makes it an excellent choice for outdoor activities and extended trips.
- OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray: While primarily an ice cube tray, it can be repurposed for making smaller block ice sections. This tray features a silicone base that allows for easy release of ice, and its sturdy construction ensures that it holds its shape while freezing.